For some, the art of delegation comes easy. They can determine what tasks can and should be delegated, who on their team is best suited for new accountabilities, and have the skills to guide and coach them throughout the process to ensure successful completion. However, for the majority of those leading a team, delegation is a struggle.
This was quantified in a study conducted by John Hunt, a professor at the London Business School, where he found that only 30% of those in charge of employees believe they can delegate well, and only 33% of them are considered a good delegators by those they lead.
There are good reasons why many leaders struggle with delegation. In an article for the BBC, Laura Lunsford, an associate professor of psychology at the University of Arizona, says, “Delegation is one of the most challenging aspects of leadership, and it actually gets harder to do the higher up someone climbs the corporate ladder.” She has found that delegators typically struggle for two primary reasons:
- It is hard to communicate what needs to be accomplished and what the expected outcome should look like, so the leader feels it is easier and will take less time to complete the task themselves.
- Loss of control. Despite delegating a task, the leader ultimately owns the success or failure that comes from that task. It can be hard to let go and trust others, especially when the consequences are high.
Part of being a great delegator is knowing what not to do. Here are the seven signs of poor delegation so you know what to avoid.
7 Signs of Poor Delegation
- You cringe when you see how a task is completed
- Struggling to articulate what needs to be done
- Delegation without the details
- Not getting commitment
- Boundaries are not set
- A set-it and forget-it mentality
- Delegating things you’re trying to avoid
You cringe when you see how a task is completed
One of the main reasons leaders resist or do not delegate is because of the loss of control. A sign of poor delegation is micromanaging how the task is completed out of fear. It can be hard to watch a team member complete a job outside of how you would have done it. However, you will miss the benefits of delegation, such as freeing up your time and creating a growth opportunity for your employee if you’re overly concerned with how the task is completed. Instead, focus on the output and end result, not how it is being done.
Struggling to articulate what needs to be done
In most cases, leaders are promoted into their roles because they were exceptional individual contributors. The skills and abilities they demonstrated in their functional role were second nature; it just came naturally to them. So when they step into a leadership role, being the one who is the delegator can be difficult as what was done without a thought for them now needs to be dissected into small steps and explained to an employee to complete the task.
Being unable to articulate the delegated task can be a telltale sign of poor delegation. Communication skills and effective leadership go hand in hand, and being a great delegator requires speaking with clarity. Brushing up on your communication skills with a communications program is an ideal place to start.
Delegation without the details
If you’ve ever been on the receiving end of delegation, you can likely relate to the scenario where you are given a task without the details. To avoid this sign of poor delegation, delegators should have the details determined before their one-on-one meeting with the employee. Then, in that conversation, the delegator should address details by answering the 5 W’s.
- Who: Who will they need to involve to complete the task? Are there other individuals, teams, departments, or outside providers that will need to contribute?
- What: What is the task that needs to be completed and describe what success looks like.
- Where: Is there any geographical information the employee needs to complete the task?
- When: One of the most important questions to answer is when the task needs to be completed? Are there any milestone deadlines during the completion of the task?
- Why: Why are you asking them to complete this task? How does completing this task fit into the big picture of the team and organization? What are the benefits of completing the task and the consequences if not? Individuals need to understand “why” to understand what is being asked of them.
- How: If needed, address how the task should be completed if there are specific details the individual needs to be aware of.
Not getting commitment
Delegating a task will never be successful if you do not get an agreement from your employee that they are willing, able, and committed to taking accountability for the assignment. Be frank and ask them, “Do you agree to take on this accountability?” to secure their commitment. Otherwise, excuses, missed deadlines, and incomplete projects are bound to happen.
Boundaries are not set
A sign of poor delegation is free for all, where employees feel they have the power to do whatever is needed to complete the task at hand. Delegating without establishing boundaries such as budget, timelines, and when they need to seek out approvals will lead to disaster. Boundaries must be set and communicated in the initial conversation the delegator has with an employee.
A set it and forget it mentality
Delegation is not one event where you have a conversation and walk away expecting the task to be completed. Instead, being a great delegator requires following a defined process of checks and balances to ensure milestones are reached, roadblocks are conquered, and the task is completed. You can get our defined process for delegators to follow in The Step-By-Step Guide to Delegation: Tips, Tricks, and Templates for Delegators.
Delegating things you’re trying to avoid
A classic sign of poor delegation and bad team leadership is delegating conversations, coaching, and conflict that a leader should address. Delegators cannot assign team members to deal with situations they’re uncomfortable with and trying to avoid, such as delivering feedback, having difficult conversations, or resolving conflict with colleagues or other teams. These are tasks that only the leader should be responsible for.
Conclusion: You Can Avoid Poor Delegation
As with learning any new skill in life, it takes time to gain knowledge and practice until it becomes second nature, and effective delegation skills are no different. A leadership development program that focuses on delegation training may be just what you need to speed up the process and avoid poor delegation.