3 min read
Why Do Managers Need Coaching Skills? What the Research Says
Imagine you walk into your annual performance review. You aren’t completely sure of what to expect, but you don’t expect anything major to come up....
7 min read
Gavin Brown
:
Jun 29, 2025 6:46:01 AM
Developing a coaching culture in the workplace isn't just about giving orders. In today's workplace, the most successful organizations have discovered something powerful: when leaders trade their directive hats for coaching ones, magic happens.
Organizations with strong coaching cultures are 51% more likely to report above-average revenue growth than those without such cultures.
But here's the thing—creating this kind of environment doesn't happen overnight. It requires intention, commitment, and a roadmap for success.
A coaching culture exists when coaching becomes embedded in an organization's DNA—where leaders at all levels use coaching approaches as their default management style. It's characterized by regular coaching conversations that empower employees to solve problems, develop skills, and reach their full potential.
A true coaching culture is one where coaching is a way of managing, a way of communicating, a way of thinking, and a way of being.
Walk into an organization with a thriving coaching culture and you'll notice something different right away:
Carol Wilson, coaching expert and founder of Culture at Work, breaks down effective coaching cultures into three essential pillars:
When these pillars stand strong, they create fertile ground where coaching behaviors can take root and flourish.
The payoff of coaching in organizations goes way beyond feel-good moments:
For team members, a coaching culture delivers tangible benefits:
Let's talk numbers. The ROI in coaching is impressive:
And these benefits compound over time as coaching behaviors become the norm throughout the organization.
Want your coaching implementation to succeed? Start at the top.
Chief People Officers and senior leaders need to walk the talk before expecting anyone else to follow. A PMI study finds that when senior leaders model coaching behaviors, program adoption across the org can jump 30–40%.
To win executive support:
Beyond the C-suite, you'll need champions throughout the organization:
Smart stakeholder mapping helps identify both allies and potential roadblocks, letting you address concerns before they derail your efforts.
Get crystal clear on why coaching matters to your specific organization. Your vision statement should:
For example: "By 2025, our organization will have a thriving coaching culture where all leaders use coaching skills daily, resulting in higher innovation, engagement, and performance."
Before diving in, take the pulse of your organization with an organizational health check to spot:
Great coaching conversations start with crystal-clear expectations and goals. Coaches help team members define what success looks like and how they'll measure it. This clarity creates focus and direction.
Coaching technique: Try asking "What does success look like?" to help team members visualize their desired outcomes before starting any project.
Effective coaching hinges on two-way communication that emphasizes:
Sounding Board client case studies report productivity lifts of 15–25% after coaching-communication training.
Coaching relationships thrive on mutual commitment to the process and outcomes. This means:
Organizations must show commitment by allocating resources and treating coaching as valuable work, not just another box to check.
Building confidence sits at the heart of effective coaching. The GROW Model (Goals, Reality, Options, Will) offers a proven framework for developing self-belief through structured conversations [Performance Consultants International].
Great coaches build confidence by:
One-off coaching efforts simply don't stick. Sustainable coaching cultures need:
The most successful organizations make coaching as routine as checking email—it's just part of how work gets done.
Transform managers into skilled coaches through comprehensive development:
Creating a network of internal coaches builds sustainable coaching capacity:
Most organizations need both approaches:
A balanced coaching program uses both approaches based on specific needs and resources.
According to research by Bruce Court, effective manager as coach skills include:
These skills should be front and center in management development programs.
To make coaching stick, weave it into existing business processes:
A study in the Schwarz Learning report shows structured coaching prompts can improve meeting-outcome efficiency by 20–25%.
Feedback is the rocket fuel that powers coaching relationships. Build feedback culture where:
Deloitte finds feedback-rich organizations experience turnover reductions of 7–10%.
Peer coaching multiplies coaching capacity throughout the organization by:
This approach democratizes coaching and builds a collaborative culture where learning happens continuously, not just in formal settings.
Peter Hawkins notes that it typically takes 6–9 months of regular coaching cycles for new skills to embed in organizational routines. Treat coaching as a daily habit through:
Take baseline measurements before launching coaching initiatives so you can accurately track progress. Track how well your coaching culture is working through multiple lenses:
Calculate ROI in coaching by examining:
The smartest approach combines hard financial metrics with qualitative outcome measures.
Coaching directly impacts how people feel about their work:
HCI/ICF research finds organizations with strong coaching cultures have engagement rates of 60% versus 48% for those without—a relative uplift of 25%.
Address the "we're too busy" challenge through:
Research from CoachHub shows that digital coaching platforms can slash time investment by 30-35% while maintaining effectiveness.
Break through resistance by:
Smart change management recognizes that resistance is natural—and requires patience, not force.
Reinforce coaching behaviors by shining a spotlight on them:
Public recognition signals what your organization truly values and encourages others to get on board.
Keep coaching skills fresh and growing through:
Best-practice frameworks recommend dedicating 10–15% of total coaching hours to coach-upskilling and peer review.
Prevent skill erosion through:
Research in the International Journal of Coaching in Organizations finds that coaching competencies can decline by 25–30% within 6 months of training without follow-up support.
Define what coaching means for your organization and why it matters. Craft a compelling vision that connects coaching to business outcomes and organizational values.
Take stock of where you are through surveys, focus groups, and leadership conversations. Identify strengths to build on and gaps to address.
Figure out who your key influencers, supporters, and potential resistors are. Develop tailored approaches for each stakeholder group.
Present a compelling business case to leadership with clear ROI projections. Secure both resources and visible executive support before rolling out more broadly.
Choose appropriate coaching models, training providers, and implementation approaches based on your unique organizational needs and culture.
Establish baseline metrics and define key performance indicators to track both implementation progress and business impact.
Start small with a focused pilot in receptive areas of the organization. Gather data and success stories to fuel broader implementation.
Assess what worked in your pilot, gather honest feedback, and make necessary adjustments before scaling up.
Roll out coaching across the organization with approaches tailored to different functions and levels.
Put in place ongoing reinforcement mechanisms, refresher training, and recognition systems to keep the coaching culture thriving over time.
3 min read
Imagine you walk into your annual performance review. You aren’t completely sure of what to expect, but you don’t expect anything major to come up....
6 min read
Buzzfeed asked their community of readers to share stories of their best bosses and what made them so great. In the article, there was a common...
9 min read
Did you know that employees whose leaders are effective coaches are 20% more likely to stay at their company, 40% more engaged with their job, and...